Over the weekend I stumbled upon "The World's Strangest UFO Stories" marathon, a 2006 show produced by the Discovery Channel. Holy crap. It was like Skeptical Viewer got its own UFO show. Think a mixture of SV and Mystery Science Theater 3000 laying the smackdown on Ancient Aliens and UFO Hunters. I don't know who the narrator was, his voice was familar, and he was appropriately snarky.
I must admit I did not get to watch much, that's what happens when you have a 2 yr old and a 2 week old running around. But, the parts I caught were every bit the skeptical show we all crave. They would give the wackos their time in the sun, then appropriately dismiss their theories.
And now the fun part. Do a search for "The World's Strangest UFO Stories" and surf some of the articles about it, particularly the comments sections.