The Forum [is where Ancient Roman skeptics hang out.]

Current User: Guest Login Register
Please consider registering


Lost Your Password?

Skeptical etiquette

Reply to Post
UserPost

12:45 pm
February 1, 2009


Stephen

San Jose, CA

Admin

posts 589

(Via the Bad Astronomy Blog)

Alyson Beatrice is a skeptic whose neighbors and friends… aren't. She frequently finds herself in situations where she needs to be polite about beliefs she doesn't share, so she consulted an etiquette expert on the subject, and wrote a blog post about it.

Stephen the Friendly Skeptic

1:16 pm
February 1, 2009


Wallydraigle

Ohio

Investigator

posts 114

Interesting.

7:19 pm
February 1, 2009


AA Adams

Investigator in Training

posts 19

I guess I tend to think more along the lines of :

PHYSICAL/SCIENTIFIC/COMMON SENSE and WHAT MAN DOESN’T KNOW YET

As opposed to:

MYSTICAL/WEIRD/WACKO and PHYSICAL/SCIENTIFIC.

(Generally speaking that is)

I definitely however, oftentimes, try to put things that are "fringy" into the PHYSICAL/SCIENTIFIC/COMMON SENSE category—can’t help it, that’s how my brain works, but I still can’t dismiss everything that falls in the "mystical" or outside western medicine or outside current scientific understanding.

There is just so much out there– that for me I would have to approach each specific topic individually and know the cutting edge of current research and have first-hand experience with a lot of "fringy" stuff before I would ever take a sweeping blanket worldview on it ALL that is so black and white— between THIS category and everything else automatically goes in THAT category. As I feel this author does, or seems to imply IMO.

I do find fault with the way man goes about some things whether discoveries, claims, miracle cures, research techniques, etc because even though I see a possibility for some things I still TEST everything and one of those tests is PHYSICAL/SCIENTIFIC/COMMON SENSE and I also consider the tendencies of man—greedy, power hungry, notoriety seeking, etc

So if someone makes a "fringy" claim to me I have to weigh the circumstances in order to decide how to handle it. Are they seeking help? an argument? a good debate? information? or just total compliance and reassurance? What is the environment it’s being discussed in? How serious are they? How much do they seem to know about their belief? How much do I know about it?

And then again sometimes I don’t consider the other person at all and just shoot my mouth off and/or insert foot. More often than I'd like too…unfortunately

11:54 pm
February 1, 2009


Learjet

Australia

Lead Investigator

posts 1122

Etiquette, it's so hard sometimes, especially when they touch on a sensitive part, which for me would be Frank's box. I guess we all have a sensitive nerve and this is mine. As a Ham radio op advanced licence this thing and the way they use it is an obscenity. Next comes the Ovilus and then 'spirit' dust orbs.  

Must resist an outburst… must remain calm… so hard…. counting backward from 100 LOL. Sealed

OD'd on EMF

4:15 pm
February 4, 2009


dr_peter_venkman

Rochester, NY

Investigator

posts 99

Learjet said:

Etiquette, it's so hard sometimes, especially when they touch on a sensitive part, which for me would be Frank's box. I guess we all have a sensitive nerve and this is mine. As a Ham radio op advanced licence this thing and the way they use it is an obscenity. Next comes the Ovilus and then 'spirit' dust orbs.  

Must resist an outburst… must remain calm… so hard…. counting backward from 100 LOL. Sealed


I hear ya. Orbs are my hot button. You really have to be sipping the cool aid to buy into those.

Hee hee hee! "Get her!" That was your whole plan, huh, "get her." Very scientific.

Reply to Post


Reply to Topic:
Skeptical etiquette

Guest Name (Required):

Guest Email (Required):

Smileys
Confused Cool Cry Embarassed Frown Kiss Laugh Smile Surprised Wink Yell
Post New Reply

Guest URL (required)

Math Required!
What is the sum of:
3 + 11
   



Permalink Print
Copyright 2010 SkepticalViewer.com - The Ghost Hunters Fansite for Skeptics