The Forum [is where Ancient Roman skeptics hang out.]

Current User: Guest Login Register
Please consider registering


Lost Your Password?

The Doctor plays Devil's Advocate again

Reply to Post
UserPost

10:24 am
June 27, 2009


The Doctor

Lead Investigator

posts 488

The KII meter will do what it says on the tin – pickup and display EMF levels.
It also seems to do a very good job detecting radio waves from handhelds, cellphones etc.
Some believe it can also be manipulated by spirits to allow conversation.

Curious that other analog or digital EMF meters do not seem to work in this capacity … in 18 years J&G were not able to get this kind of results.

So, what can we make of this ?

Now follow me … :-)   Current paranormal theory says that EVP's are NOT caused by acoustic sounds, but by the spirits manipulating the innards of the recorders to put their sounds on the recording media.

What if the spirits are NOT changing the EMF level, but screwing with the insides of the KII to manipulate the lights ? Could a penny jammed in the switch just happen to be exactly the type of "antenna" the ghosts need to enable this ?

11:23 am
June 27, 2009


Sheetie Attitude

Investigator

posts 50

The Doctor said:

What if the spirits are NOT changing the EMF level, but screwing with the insides of the KII to manipulate the lights ? Could a penny jammed in the switch just happen to be exactly the type of "antenna" the ghosts need to enable this ?


The Doctor - An interesting thought. 

Some people suggest using a small piece of folded cardboard or a coin.  However, I don't have any data as to the success rate of perceived conversation with an EMF meter for cardboard jamming vs. penny jamming. 

11:32 am
June 27, 2009


Stephen

San Jose, CA

Admin

posts 589

If that's the case, then they should save time and money by just using a box with LEDs. Far harder to get accidental false positives with that. Add a coin to the works someplace to test the "cointenna" idea, if you like.

Also, J&G did get results with other EMF meters. They then try to use those results to explain paranormal symptoms as electromagnetic sensitivity (if they don't want the place to be haunted) or as spectral manifestations (if they do).

If ghosts do these things by manipulating the insides of electronic gadgets, then why do they not mostly talk to dead electrical engineers?

Stephen the Friendly Skeptic

11:52 am
June 27, 2009


blinddog

Special Agent Zombie Elimination Agency

Moderator

posts 857

They get the same results by pushing the switch with their thumb, but then, the human body can act as an antenna also.
Then there's the dilemma of the KII's with a toggle switch on the side.

I agree with Stephen, any spirit capable of manipulating transistors, diodes and capacitors with a low power EMF field shouldn't have any trouble with simple LEDs.

Double tap to the head. Don't become Undead.

12:50 pm
June 27, 2009


The Doctor

Lead Investigator

posts 488

Stephen-"If that's the case, then they should save time and money by just using a box with LEDs."

Sure, they could try it … along with many other variations to see if they equal or exceed their current "success" rate.  I'm sure we would all encourage experimentation to refine their results.

Stephen- "Also, J&G did get results with other EMF meters."

I don't recall any conversations matching the amazing results from the KII, but maybe it just takes a much stonger spirit to get into other types of meters.

especially like this non-broadcast event     http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=woSmmy6dvIc

blinddog50 -"I agree with Stephen, any spirit capable of manipulating transistors, diodes and capacitors with a low power EMF field shouldn't have any trouble with simple LEDs."

Missed my point – My contention is that it is NOT manipulating the EMF that creates the result in the KII's in the same way that EVP are not a manipulation of air in hitting the microphone.   In any case we have no information to believe that spiriits have and can put forth enough energy to light an LED without an independant power source and control circuits.

IF J&G were actual investigators, I'm sure we could come up with dozens of variations ( larger 100% copper "antenna", actual connection to likely points in the circuit, etc. ) for them to try out on their cooperative ghosts.

8:41 am
June 28, 2009


Learjet

Australia

Lead Investigator

posts 1122

I really don't think a jammed coin or side toggle is going to change much with the circuit. Especially a coin since there is no electrical contact, and a small coin is not the sort of thing that would inductively couple itself to this type of circuit. 

A side toggle switch will have stuff all effect on the circuit as the on board switch is already connected to a long battery lead.

There is nothing special about any of the components in the K2 itself. All the components are common garden variety LM324N and PN100, PN200 power amps from the 1980's.

What is different from the K2 that sets it apart from other "EMF" meters is that the K2 has no filtering to block signals of shorter wavelength. As we know, this means pretty much anything up to the operational frequency of the PN100/200's ( a few hundred MegaHertz) will break through. What we end up with is a meter that's sensitive from just a few Hertz to a few hundred MegaHertz. It's like combining an "EMF" meter with an "RF" meter. (Please egg-scuse the quotation marks as technically EMF is RF and RF is EMF, although in the ghost hunting world EMF has come to be known as low frequency and RF high frequency.) Phew.

In tests, I've been able to trigger the K2 from hundreds of metres away on VHF with about 50 watts. Theoretically this means any vehicle with a two way radio (police, ambulance, ham, cb, commercial) may be able to activate a K2 if they were driving nearby and transmitting at the time, depending on radio power, antenna, gain and mount position etc.

Since there is no frequency display, this makes the K2 a false hits nightmare. Beware anyone who uses this meter without backup monitering equipment.

Stay awake, I'm not finished yet. Now I will tell a little story.

A close relative died just after I got the K2. The day after I went to my sister's place for dinner and thought I'd take along the K2 for a little electrical ouija fun. I went to start the car and all the electrical systems went crazy. The dash lights were blinking on and off, relays were going berserk etc. Second try I got the car started with the rest of the trip uneventful. The car has never done this before or since (not that I've had it that long).

After dinner I placed the K2 on the table and tried getting the attention of our dead relative. At one point the meter's lights rapidly blinked up to the orange LED. However further tries at contact produced no results.

Now my sister lives in a rural area with no neighbours closer than maybe 75 metres away. I don't see any antennas on their roof. There  is a busy road half a kilometre away and a railway track 100 metres away, otherwise it's a dead end road.

I'm kicking myself that I didn't take the laptop with spectrum lab and a radio scanner. For the last few visits to my sister's I have taken the K2 (this time with a scanner), set it on at the same time of night and have not had any further activations from it. That little event with the car and meter annoys me and fascinates me at the same time. 

So the question remains. Can ghosts mess with electrical systems? Yes I know, I can think of 1001 ways it can happen naturally also, yet……..

OD'd on EMF

10:04 am
June 28, 2009


The Doctor

Lead Investigator

posts 488

Learjet said:

I really don't think a jammed coin or side toggle is going to change much with the circuit.

Since there is no frequency display, this makes the K2 a false hits nightmare. Beware anyone who uses this meter without backup monitering equipment.


( remember, I'm still DA here :-)

Some psychics claim they can hold a coin or piece of jewelry, and tell all sorts of information about the spirits.  Since the  "energy" that holds and imparts this information is unknown,  there is no way to decide if a coin would make the KII more receptive other then testing.  J&G's results appear to support my theory, thei rejection of the installed switch could very well have been because they did not get results.

Now … just what about the video I linked above ?

Supposedly, the same basic conversation was held with this same spirit over 3 days. Since the video we see does not appear to be cut'n'paste like the TV shows, we must rule out exterraneous RF as the multitude of questions are asked and answered "correctly"

It seems there are only a few possibilities -

1)  the entire video was staged for reasons we don't know – perhaps some kind of test or pilot filming for Pilgrim.

2)  J&G are Frauds and Charletans, taking money in small bites from the gullible.

3) J&G have stumbled across proof of an afterlife, perhaps the greatest discovery in history ( after fire ). Yet, for some unfathomable reason, these investigators who have spent decades in research, prefer to remain plumbers and innkeepers.

With proof like this, their discovery should in a very short time allow them to purchace both the Stanley Hotel and the Mount Washington Hotel & Resort if they wish to keep their wives and family happy.

Believers and skeptics alike should be demanding to know just why J & G have chosen to keep the proof out of public view.

10:44 am
June 28, 2009


Learjet

Australia

Lead Investigator

posts 1122

Sorry, I've been having trouble with youtube but I can play it now.

I would rule out 1). We were talking to the guy who shot the video (valpro99) on the TAPS forum. He was one fellow in a public group that investigate with J&G after the TV shoot. You know, the one where you pay $350 for, the gold package I think they call it. He is an active member of the TAPS forums that I've (typed) with and I believe he is genuine.

It's one of the few K2 videos on youtube that I find truely interesting.

However, suspect number uno with a big G is all over it. Is he really showing that the meters are not rigged or is he up to no good? This would leave the skeptic with no option but option 2. Does Grant have something to set off a K2 up his sleeve? In front of all those people and camcorders? 

I dunno, if G wasn't there I reckon I would cave in and say it's a spook! But he bothers me.

OD'd on EMF

10:49 am
June 28, 2009


Learjet

Australia

Lead Investigator

posts 1122

Nearly forgot, the psychometry thing doesn't work with coins I'm told as it's passed through too many hands. It has to be something that has a connection to one person and be handled by few people as possible.

OD'd on EMF

12:16 pm
June 28, 2009


Wallydraigle

Ohio

Investigator

posts 114

Like poop?  No, wait, don't just write me off.  Poop is ever only touched by one person, as a rule.  For that one person, it spends at least several hours inside their body as a discrete poop.  Before that, as food it was carefully selected by that specific person for qualities they approve of.  They could have eaten anything, but the psychic vibrations called out to them, and they put that particular food into their bodies, which would later become the poop in question. 

But it goes beyond that.  Poop is a very personal thing.  It has sloughed-off intestinal cells in it.  Cells from one person and one person only.  Bilirubin, the brown pigment that gives poop it's characteristic color, comes from the hemoglobin from old blood cells which have faithfully discharged their duty and muct now be replaced.  Blood that has pumped through us for weeks.  It is our life.  We pour our life blood into our poop.  We are in our poop.  Our poop is us!

I posit that psychics take to handling poop for their readings, because there's nothing more personal, and it should give superb results.

12:21 pm
June 28, 2009


The Doctor

Lead Investigator

posts 488

Learjet said:

Sorry, I've been having trouble with youtube but I can play it now.

I would rule out 1). We were talking to the guy who shot the video (valpro99) on the TAPS forum. He was one fellow in a public group that investigate with J&G after the TV shoot. You know, the one where you pay $350 for, the gold package I think they call it. He is an active member of the TAPS forums that I've (typed) with and I believe he is genuine.

I dunno, if G wasn't there I reckon I would cave in and say it's a spook! But he bothers me.


If we've ruled out 1) , and I think you agree with me that this cannot be some kind of "mistake" on J&G's part where they are not competant enough to find a non-paranormal reason for the replies, we are left with 2 and 3.

j & G's actions are simply not those of investigaters who after 18+ years have found the repeatable proof that they have been searching for … they have finally found the handle to open up the door to the paranormal and be able to discover and provide real help to those who have called on them. ( not to mention becoming rich and famous beyond their wive's wildest dreams )

Their actions are of those who do not wish anyone to look closely at their results.

If this were real, they would not have to keep repeating that foolish statement about needing to keep the plumbing jobs for when the show's run finally ends.

OH – as far as the coin goes, your comment seems to agree that a coin can act as a conduit for spirit energy, according to believers.  I don't see it as a big stretch to think a spirit nearby or touching it could overwhelm any residual energy left over from past owners.

9:36 pm
June 28, 2009


Learjet

Australia

Lead Investigator

posts 1122

Lol Wally, I think I know what you're taking  to the next psychometry meeting.

Getting back to the K2, I can think of a couple of ways this session could have happened – IF it was a setup.

Firstly, anyone in the room could have a transmitter. Might have been G, might have been someone else where our attention was not directed. G might have been a decoy.

Second, the room could have been miked and a more powerful transmitter could be in another room or close by to respond to questions.

Three, who supplied the K2's? G? Might not have been real K2's but have innards swapped out for other electronics. Etc etc.

If any of the above are correct, then Ghost Hunters is just a big on the road magic show. I guess I've never really thought of them quite like that. Rather I see them being fooled by equipment misuse and lack of understanding, with the odd magic trick thrown in by G to spice things up a bit.

I'm not sure I'm ready for the final leap of skeptisism just yet, that the entire thing is carefully planned from start to finish…. but I'll keep it in mind.

OD'd on EMF

12:17 am
June 29, 2009


Revenant

Hopelessly Locked In A "Fear Cage"

Lead Investigator

posts 1393

The Doctor said:

Some psychics claim they can hold a coin or piece of jewelry, and tell all sorts of information about the spirits.  Since the  "energy" that holds and imparts this information is unknown,  there is no way to decide if a coin would make the KII more receptive other then testing.  J&G's results appear to support my theory, thei rejection of the installed switch could very well have been because they did not get results.


Um…no.  And here's why:

1)  You state "J&G's results appear to support my theory, their rejection of the installed switch could very well have been because they did not get results."  Inaction does not necessarily mean confirmation of your "theory."  J&G saw a problem with holding down the button on the K2.  They "fixed" it by shoving a penny above the plastic button so it would be continually "on."  To them, the problem is solved.  To state "their rejection" is to imply that there has been testing for comparison.  To imply that they have not gotten the same results with a K2 meter with an installed switch is unsubstantiated.  Unless you have evidence of testing done by J&G or TAPS using both the penny and the switch and the results of those tests, then you do not have a theory, you have an assumption.  An unsupported and an incorrect assumption.

2)  Learjet stated: "I really don't think a jammed coin or side toggle is going to change much with the circuit. Especially a coin since there is no electrical contact, and a small coin is not the sort of thing that would inductively couple itself to this type of circuit."

In which you responded with: "Some psychics claim they can hold a coin or piece of jewelry, and tell all sorts of information about the spirits.  Since the  "energy" that holds and imparts this information is unknown,  there is no way to decide if a coin would make the KII more receptive other then testing."

So…we are jumping from electrical engineering and physics to…magic?  I do not recall J&G talking about how pennies "hold and impart information."  I do not recall J&G stating "There's a theory that some psychics can hold a coin…etc."  I do not understand how the magical properties of the penny are being attributed to J&G and the K2 when, to my knowledge, it has not been stated on the actual show.

3) You state: "OH – as far as the coin goes, your comment seems to agree that a coin can act as a conduit for spirit energy, according to believers.  I don't see it as a big stretch to think a spirit nearby or touching it could overwhelm any residual energy left over from past owners."  What?  What "believers" are you referring to?  Are these supposed to be the fans of GH?  A spirit could overwhelm any residual energy left over from past owners?  Again, I am just not seeing how this applies to GH or J&G.  I can also not get past the fact that even if there was some "energy" or whatever, the penny has no electrical contact with anything.  We're still talking "magic" when it comes to how that penny would interact with the circuitry within the K2.

Lastly, I am of full support of Wallydraigle's suggestion.  I cannot think of a better object or substance for psychics to handle. 

"Skepticism is not a position, it's a process." -Dr Michael Shermer

10:06 am
June 29, 2009


The Doctor

Lead Investigator

posts 488

@Learjet -  You are correct in that IF it is a setup, there are many ways for it to be accomplished, but I don't think any of them makes sense without J&G's involvement. IF they are involved, it can be done very simply.

@Revanant- 

 My "their rejection" stems from the fact that in one of the shows they DID use a KII with a switch, and they HAVE made statements that they do not use them anymore since they don't know what effect it has on the proper operation.  It's not a big leap to surmise that they did not get the results they were looking for when they used the units with switches.  Perhaps you have statements from J&G that they did NOT do any testing ? … or are you simply assuming ?

It's obvious to all of us that J&G do very little in the way of experimentation to refine their techniques or explain their results. 

" I can also not get past the fact that even if there was some "energy" or whatever, the penny has no electrical contact with anything. "   – Learjet might be willing to fill you in on passive antenna elements.

10:46 am
June 29, 2009


Revenant

Hopelessly Locked In A "Fear Cage"

Lead Investigator

posts 1393

The Doctor said:

" I can also not get past the fact that even if there was some "energy" or whatever, the penny has no electrical contact with anything. "   – Learjet might be willing to fill you in on passive antenna elements.


Cool.  Maybe he can also explain to me how a penny can store information and how a spirit nearby or touching it could overwhelm any residual energy left over from past owners as well because you completely lost me there.

"Skepticism is not a position, it's a process." -Dr Michael Shermer

11:28 am
June 29, 2009


Mary

Pondering what you're pondering

Investigator

posts 147

Pennies have the power to store information?  Surprised  And now the Government wants to do away with them?  I smell a conspiracy, here.   

We need to get a petition together, so the penny can be saved!  After all, how many coins can also be used to extend the life of a fuse?  *loud bang sounds from electrical box, followed by billowing black smoke…*

"Quando omni flunkus moritati" ("When all else fails, play dead") – Possum Lodge motto. Jason and Grant should adopt it as their own.

11:48 am
June 29, 2009


Learjet

Australia

Lead Investigator

posts 1122

The Doctor said:

" I can also not get past the fact that even if there was some "energy" or whatever, the penny has no electrical contact with anything. "   – Learjet might be willing to fill you in on passive antenna elements.


The short answer is that a penny doesn't have any noticeable effect on the K2.

Long answer…

Shoving a coin into the switch slot appears to make no difference to the performance of the meter at 50 Hz, 28MHz, 50MHz, 144MHz, 432 MHz or 1296MHz.

Grasping the meter with my hand makes a difference in some cases. Mostly it makes the readings higher, sometimes lower.

The meter is in plastic box so it's not immune to capacitive coupling from our body. The same thing happens with the Gauss Master. The body is acting as an antenna. This is not a precision instrument.

There are two steel screws in the back cover, one going through the circuit board. They would have about as much relevance as a coin in the slot.

Now for a really nasty test, I just stuck a small but powerful rare earth magnet on the switch. This quite surprised me, as long as the magnet is stationary relative to the meter, it has little effect on the readings. Of course the magnet is producing a DC or magnetostatic field around the meter which this AC meter appears to ignore completely – unless of course the magnet is moving relative to the meter in which case the field changes to AC and the meter detects.

Well these tests just reinforce my idea that a coin does nothing.

Any other tests you would like me to do?

OD'd on EMF

12:36 pm
June 29, 2009


The Doctor

Lead Investigator

posts 488

Revenant-


Cool.  Maybe he can also explain to me how a penny can store information and how a spirit nearby or touching it could overwhelm any residual energy left over from past owners as well because you completely lost me there.


Don't think that's within his specialties. but perhaps this would help -

Take a meter, a rechargeable battery and it's charger.

The charger must be at a higher potential then the battery so it can overwhelm and "force" energy into it.

When the charger is connected, the meter will read higher then reading the battery alone.

It's the charger that is being read, not the charge allready stored.

As far as the coin itself holding information, at the present time it appears that no one knows the type of energy that may be  involved BUT the method might be something akin to bubble memory where a solid slab of material has been used to store information.

You almost seem to be saying that anything not yet understood cannot exist. 

12:46 pm
June 29, 2009


The Doctor

Lead Investigator

posts 488

Learjet said:

Well these tests just reinforce my idea that a coin does nothing.

Any other tests you would like me to do?


If you recall, my concept is that the spirit is NOT creating a EMF field change that effects the meter, akin to  an EVP where a spirit does NOT create an acoustic pressure change at the microphone.

Now, if you had a cooperative ghost like J&G at Ft. Mifflin, you could actually do the test under the correct conditions.

When you find Casper, I'm sure I can suggest dozens of tests Laughing

Reply to Post


Reply to Topic:
The Doctor plays Devil's Advocate again

Guest Name (Required):

Guest Email (Required):

Smileys
Confused Cool Cry Embarassed Frown Kiss Laugh Smile Surprised Wink Yell
Post New Reply

Guest URL (required)

Math Required!
What is the sum of:
6 + 2
   



Permalink Print
Copyright 2010 SkepticalViewer.com - The Ghost Hunters Fansite for Skeptics