The Forum [is where Ancient Roman skeptics hang out.]

Current User: Guest Login Register
Please consider registering


Lost Your Password?

GHI S02E13A Cartago,Costa Rica Duran Sanitorium

Reply to Post
UserPost

7:48 pm
February 21, 2010


The Doctor

Lead Investigator

posts 488

The most important piece of evidence presented to the client is a photo which purports to show a little girl ghostie sitting at the bottom of some steps.

This website claims to be that of  Paul Bradford,  the GHI team member

http://cgh.minnesotaghosts.com/index.php?option=com_kunena&Itemid=60&func=view&catid=13&id=201#409

…and he gives us enhanced screen captures of the image – it appears that even members don't get access to the original images.

What is very curious here is that there seems to be a problem of scale – at about 5:40 in, Paul himself is seen at those steps, and a rough estimate would put this little girl at less then 2 ft tall. One has to wonder why Paul and the rest of the team don't notice this.

10:18 am
February 22, 2010


Learjet

Australia

Lead Investigator

posts 1075

Good catch Doc.

This is why this sort of stuff, if they are at all serious, needs to be put out for peer review to see if it holds up to criticism.

OD'd on EMF

11:13 am
February 22, 2010


The Doctor

Lead Investigator

posts 488

Learjet said:

Good catch Doc.

This is why this sort of stuff, if they are at all serious, needs to be put out for peer review to see if it holds up to criticism.


I give Paul a lot of credit for digging further into his image, even with no access to the originals, but it appears that he stopped thinking critically when he got what he wanted.

As an example of this type of thinking we can go 'way back to the FLIR image on the Crescent Hotel locker, Jason simply declares it an appirition and that's the final answer … but …. then we have the problem of Casper's head being just a bit larger then the "2".

The only possible conclusion is that this appirition is some kind of leprechaun floating in the air.

7:56 pm
February 22, 2010


Paul

Guest

Hey Guys, its great to see people discussing this photo and I can certainly understand how you would come to the idea that I was pretty close to the step but in fact thats just how that particular scene was edited, in fact when I was taking these photos Barry was inside the building snapping more photographs.  I was actually a good distance from the steps.  When analyzing the photo ourselves based on the information we had we estimated the girl to be roughly 3.5ft maybe 4ft obviously it is difficult to be 100% especially when we are as you rightly said attempting to remain skeptical and more importantly unbias.  The image of the Ghost Girl only appeared the once in a series of more than 10 photos.

It certainly is nice to get something like this, and I wont lie, I was very excited to see it. Especially as this was one of the reports. However with anything you have to take a step back, calm down and look at alternatives.  It is of my personal opinion that we have caught something very interesting in this photo and that it is not a case of matrixing.  What it is I cannot say 100%, I know what it looks like and I know what others in the team think it looks like and we all came to the same conclusion.  With that said none of us claim to be professionals. 

Heres an extract from my Forum:

Ive been using the FS Illuminator for sometime and this was the first time I got a result from using it, so can I say that its because of the FSI that we caught this image or was it just luck? Would I have still caught the image without the use of the FSI, using just the flash or using Nightshot? I dont know, What was it about the FSI that allowed me to see the image these are all questions that require more experimentation.

I think Im still somewhat critical…

Paul Bradford
Ghost Hunters International (GHI),
SyFy Channel, USA.
http://www.syfy.com/ghi

Paul Bradford
Creepy Hollow Gear
P.O. Box 22336
Tucson, Az 85734
http://www.creepyhollowgear.com

10:20 am
February 23, 2010


The Doctor

Lead Investigator

posts 488


Hi Paul, and thanks for the info.

Can I ask how you came to the 3.5 – maybe 4 ft height estimate for the girl figure ?

Just so I'm clear on this, the figure is supposed to look as if she is sitting on the top concrete step with her back to the 1st vertical of the railing ?

If so, there is another problem -

When you guys were going back down those stairs during the walkthrough, the cameraman and editors flashes a nice "artsy" sequence of shots as the camera travels down the stairs. The last frame in this sequence clearly shows looking vertically downward at the bottom of the stars and the concrete steps.  There is NO step in the position where the supposed little girl is sitting.

Reply to Post


Reply to Topic:
GHI S02E13A Cartago,Costa Rica Duran Sanitorium

Guest Name (Required):

Guest Email (Required):

Smileys
Confused Cool Cry Embarassed Frown Kiss Laugh Smile Surprised Wink Yell
Post New Reply

Guest URL (required)

Math Required!
What is the sum of:
3 + 12
   



Permalink Print
Copyright 2010 SkepticalViewer.com - The Ghost Hunters Fansite for Skeptics