The Forum [is where Ancient Roman skeptics hang out.]

Current User: Guest Login Register
Please consider registering


Lost Your Password?

UserPost

7:13 am
April 16, 2010


Mary

Pondering what you're pondering

Investigator

posts 147

Here is a quote from the SyFy Destination Truth site -

"During an EVP session, the Josh hears the clear sound of someone chanting in the distance. It almost sounds like someone moaning on the wind. When he asks, "Is anyone here?" he gets a clearly audible response: "Yes.""

Question.  Why would ancient spirits living in Petra understand English, much less reply in English?

Jason and Grant were so impressed, too.  Cool

"Quando omni flunkus moritati" ("When all else fails, play dead") – Possum Lodge motto. Jason and Grant should adopt it as their own.

7:25 am
April 16, 2010


jcarton

Guest

Sounded like Ryder to me.

7:35 am
April 16, 2010


Mary

Pondering what you're pondering

Investigator

posts 147

I've also just noticed they call him 'the Josh' (that quote was 'cut and pasted' directly from the SyFy site).  So is The Josh sorta like The Donald?  LOL!

"Quando omni flunkus moritati" ("When all else fails, play dead") – Possum Lodge motto. Jason and Grant should adopt it as their own.

12:21 pm
April 16, 2010


The Doctor

Lead Investigator

posts 488

Mary said:

 When he asks, "Is anyone here?" he gets a clearly audible response: "Yes.""

Jason and Grant were so impressed, too.  Cool


Bring back the good old days when J&G skoffed at one word, one syllable EVPs.

Almost every time someone says " did you hear that? " it could have been taken as an answer to some question if one were being asked at that moment.

An interesting point was when the base team said they saw someone sitting in the ampithetre tunnel. Ryder goes to check it out and we see her arrive there, finding nothing out of the ordinary. Since the shadows that looked like a figure were not, the incident should have been dismissed. 

At best it could have been used as a learning opportunity … Ryder could have been directed to the areas that seemed like a figure and been able to report on what was actually causing it to look that way on IR.

Why does Ryder decide to do an EVP session instead ?

11:19 pm
April 17, 2010


JM

Guest

Gates's comment "So…it's the ghost of a bug or a bird?'  made the episode for me.   : )

As for the "yes"…that's clearly echo of their own voices, possibly mixed with wind…classic aural matrixing, and not even a good example.  You have to _try_ to hear that "yes".   The natural acoustics of caves distort sound and echo like all get out; it's only natural that you'd eventually hear/record a sound that was warped to the tone our brains auto-identify as being a human voice.

This is a big part of why I don't trust EVPs anymore; it's either the natural acoustics of the environment messing with your ears, or, much more often, the recording equipemtn picking up stray radio/cel phone signals. The latter was not the case here, but….food for thought:  unplug your speakers from your computer sometime, but leave them powered up/turned on, and listen fto what shows up in the resultant static for a few hours.  You'll get an "EVP" or two, almost guaranteed.

I do wish this stuff were real, and that there really were psycho-kinesis prone "negative entities" out there like Jason describes; it'd make the world a more magical and fascinating place to live in….but one has to look at the hard and painful facts eventually.

Even my own, sole "paranormal experience" that I personally observed, I have to acknowledge as fitting all too well with the occasional auditory and visual hallucinations that the human brain hiccups into being every now and again.

That said….for the few reliable accounts of paranormal phenomena that I've encountered, I must say I'm more inclined to lean towards it being a spasm of quantum physics, a momentary bleeding of one paralell universe into the other,  than I am to believe it  being the work of anything close to a deceased human.

11:52 am
April 19, 2010


Lindy

Guest

I am wondering just how "remote", that this place is. I realise that it isn't downtown Chicago, however there was both a stray cat and dog seen so I imagine that civilization is near and that the place could be subject to exterior noise pollution. How secure could it be as well?

11:59 am
April 19, 2010


Lindy

Guest

I also realise how to spell realize…………….just a little late

1:28 pm
April 19, 2010


jcarton

Guest

Lindy said:

I am wondering just how "remote", that this place is. I realise that it isn't downtown Chicago, however there was both a stray cat and dog seen so I imagine that civilization is near and that the place could be subject to exterior noise pollution. How secure could it be as well?


For those interested  http://www.visitjordan.com/Default.aspx?Tabid=63

or  http://www.petrapark.com/

4:19 pm
April 19, 2010


hyacinth

Investigator

posts 116

Thanks jcarton , I checked out petrapark.com and I had no idea there was that much to it .

10:06 am
April 20, 2010


Mary

Pondering what you're pondering

Investigator

posts 147

My brother was there just last fall, and he said the place was MASSIVE.  The parts you always see on TV or in the movies is just a tiny section. 

"Quando omni flunkus moritati" ("When all else fails, play dead") – Possum Lodge motto. Jason and Grant should adopt it as their own.

1:28 pm
April 22, 2010


Bobarino

Valencia, CA

Investigator

posts 181

Lindy said:

I am wondering just how "remote", that this place is. I realise that it isn't downtown Chicago, however there was both a stray cat and dog seen so I imagine that civilization is near and that the place could be subject to exterior noise pollution. How secure could it be as well?


As the main investigation begins, you can see what looks like city lights in the not-too-far distance (in the IR)

I've found that being AWESOME is a full time job…

Reply to Post


Reply to Topic:
Petra

Guest Name (Required):

Guest Email (Required):

Smileys
Confused Cool Cry Embarassed Frown Kiss Laugh Smile Surprised Wink Yell
Post New Reply

Guest URL (required)

Math Required!
What is the sum of:
3 + 9
   



Permalink Print
Copyright 2010 SkepticalViewer.com - The Ghost Hunters Fansite for Skeptics