September 24, 2009

GH: Church of St. Andrew

The Church of St. Andrew is a place with some interesting history. Originally constructed in 1712, the church was expanded upon several times in it's history, each time encroaching more and more on the graveyard that was next to the building. Apparently no one had realized quite how much the church had moved over the graveyard until 1989 when human remains from 17 bodies were found during construction in the church's basement.

A number of different paranormal-type experiences have been reported in the building and on the grounds, but most of them border on the mundane. I know it's not in good taste, but I nearly laughed when they interviewed the caretaker and he said sometimes when he was alone in the church he "felt a presence". Normally this is just the generalized sort of thing I think most investigators can safely ignore and write off as the general human tendency to creep one-self out, but dude it's a church! Aren't you supposed to feel a presence?

I mean, maybe it's wrong to assume someone who works in a church is probably a religious man but upon "feeling a presence" wouldn't the natural assumption be 'God' or 'The Holy Spirit' and not 'it must be a ghost' ?

There were some more interesting reports though. One in particular was a photograph that was taken in the basement/catacombs area of the church which shows what appears to be a noose — which also happens to be partially transparent and wasn't actually there according to the photographer). Something like that might possibly be explained by a common photographic glitch, but if so then the shape of the anomaly as well as it's prominent location in the photograph would be a sizable coincidence. Of course, Steve and Tango quickly agree that it's a piece of lint so maybe that's it, I dunno.

Also there was the tale of the drummer boy who has been seen by some, walking through the graveyard, but more often his drums have been heard — by many people including the Priest who gave TAPS their tour of the property.

As the team began their investigation Grant said, "We're not going to treat this place any differently just because it is a church".  I hope that doesn't mean Jay's going to climb up onto the altar with his shoes on as if it was a client's bed.

In fact, we do see Jay start climbing up on some of the less holy parts of the church in his quest to determine what might make a candle suddenly burn brighter for no apparent reason, and also cause a set of heavy chimes to ring. It turns out his climbing wasn't necessary anyway, as the answer seemed to come from the floor — right beneath both the candle and chimes was a vent in the floor for a forced-hot-air system. The hypothesis being that if the air turned on (by the thermostat) all of sudden it would cause the candle to burn brighter (due to the additional oxygen moving through the flame) and cause the chimes to move. They didn't manage to prove it, but the location of the vent combined with the reported phenomena seemed to coincidental not to be connected.

In the chapel, Kris and Amy began hearing sounds they hadn't hear (nor had Jay & Grant) earlier. They asked it to come closer to them and the sounds seemed to oblige. They detailed that the sound seemed to come from near the altar at first, then halfway thrrough the congregation (but apparently still near a wall) and then from the wall just nearby. I wonder if this isn't the heat/air coming on. The girl noted it as odd but couldn't reach any conclusion beyond that.

Outside Steve & Tango searched for the drummer boy. Right away it seemed that they'd heard something, but quickly lost interest in whatever it was and dropped into  an existential conversation about life after death, heaven, hell and free will. Steve, apparently bored, decided for no good reason that if he took two sticks and played "snare drum" on the stub of a tree branch he might be able to lure the drummer boy out, but alas it was not to be.

From the reveal it was very clear that their host, Father Michael, was very keen on believing his church was haunted by a benign spirit (other than the Holy Spirit) and his enthusiasm didn't seem the least bit dampened by TAPS basically telling they hadn't found anything paranormal but had some very good debunks. They did apparently confirm with local historians that a little drummer boy was shot and buried on the property, so that was interesting. I am a poor boy too, pa rum pum pum pum.

Filed under Ghost Hunters, Posts by

Permalink Print Comment

Comments on GH: Church of St. Andrew »

September 25, 2009

M. Roget @ 7:51 am

Just a small, somewhat giggle-worthy observation made during Kris/Amy's little jaunt into the St. Andrew's "catacombs"- on 2nd viewing there seemed to be an old portrait of a Victorian era woman in a wire basket on the floor next to Kris while she was expounding on something or other. The face was post-prod. fuzzed out. Privacy issues? Didn't get the old gal's sig on a release form? Not quite. The portrait was fuzzed because it's one of those Halloween lenticular pictures called a "Gortrait":

http://www.allholidaytreasures.com/Merchant2/merchant.mvc?Screen=PROD&Product_Code=HTTA329&Category_Code=10gortraits

Between the Gortrait & the newish-looking "toe pincher" wooden coffin leaning against the back wall in many shots, one might think that St. Andrew stores some Halloween Haunt props down in their catacombs. Ah, Halloween haunts- always a great fundraiser & kid pleaser for any parish to put on around this time of year.

Brenny @ 8:41 am

a three foot ten year old? what?

StanTheMan @ 10:24 am

It is very telling that when Jason supposedly sees the mass he says "did you see that" and Grant answers "what was that". He doesn't mention what he saw until after Jason has told him or should I say clued him. This has become an investigation staple and is usually at the first commercial.

I may have my espisode wrong but it's the same in every one.

Angelayo1970 @ 10:55 am

Oh ugh! That was in the Benton House one but you are so right Stan! That stuck out like a sore thumb. He totally missed the production meeting on that one!

Producer: "So Jason, you say you saw a black shadowy figure and Grant, you agree. Got it?"

Jason: Got it.

Grant: Wha…? Uh, yeah, got it!

TasCat @ 11:19 am

I thought both investigations were pretty lackluster. There seemed to be no enthusiam, at times it appeared that Kris and Amy were doing evp sessions sans digital voice recorder.
Both episodes neglected to show the boring evaluation of footage scene (yay!) as well as I don't remember seeing the moon through the clouds in time lapse!

I was kind of wondering if the pastor/priest forgot to take his pills that morning, he sure was hyper! But another episode where Jay and Grant see something, but no one else does, the shadow in the church, and the 3 1/2 foot tall 10 year old…poor kid. Plus they break out the laptop for the reveal in both, so we the viewers in anticipation of seeing some other evidence they may have found, get kicked in the pants.

Again, I think they just threw a "sighting" in each one to at least get us to stay until the reveals.

A quick note on a very old episode…Brian and Steve are examining evidence, it's Steve's idea to fast forward through stuff, messing around, burping and blowing it in Brian's face…but Brian gets the heat. Makes me think that Brian had a good reason to leave, it was probably one of those "I quit!" "No, you're fired!" situations..who knows. Sad when the rerun was more interesting than the new episode though. Like listening to a joke who's punchline you already know, but you giggle anyway.

I was just plain unimpressed and disappointed, no FLIR, limited EMF detection, lackluster evp work, even depressing when Kris was "provoking" the British Soldiers, not provoking, downright taunting, I expected her to stick her tongue out and go "Nyah, Nyah, Nyah!"

The Doctor @ 12:13 pm

@M. Roget –

Great catch on the gortrait – That kind of explains the cat skeleton that freaks out Amy also … just another prop that suckers an experienced ghost hunter.

At about that same time, Kris says something like " alright chimes .." and we hear some chimes sounding.
If she is mentioning them to flag them on the audio tape as non-evp, which would mean they are a regular occurance, why is that never explained ?

ARE there regular chimes that go off in that church ?

On another forum it was questioned that the wind would nver be able to sound the chimes up in the church as they are very heavy – well, just how DO they sound then ?

Perhaps some automatic timer that could get messed up and ring them wrong until it gets reset ?

Mary @ 12:27 pm

Speaking of that upright coffin, does anyone here remember the old Svengoolie show out of various Chicago TV stations? This 'ghoul' hosted late night horror movies. He would stand in a coffin just like that, and throw rubber chickens. I kept waiting for those rubber chickens to start flying around Kris and Amy's heads.

BERWYN!?!?!?

Mary @ 12:38 pm

For those of you that have never seen The Sven, here is a YouTube video of a Svengoolie skit. I hope the link works.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AchkTcnE5Jw

Tkfourtwo1 @ 1:44 pm

It is becoming painfully clear that TAPS doesn't really care anymore. It is almost uncomfortable to watch them go through the motions. The unenthusiastic way they deal with clients now reminds me that scene in "Galaxy Quest" where the cast went to the opening of the appliance store and just said their lines to get paid.

Also, if I have to hear Jason say "Is that it?" when taking a tour, I may just put the show on mute. I loved seasons 1 & 2, but sure not what it used to be…

HollyDolly @ 4:01 pm

Some churches do have chimes or bells that go off usually on the hour.
I don't know if churches use an actual person to ring the bells anymore,but they do have some sort of computer program i think now a days where they can go and set the chimes to go off at certain times. This maybe a feature of the church.It is also possible that the mechanism that makes the chimes go off has some sort of short maybe.
They should have looked into that so it could be debunked. I mention that in case that's one of the claims that they go off at odd hours, especially late at night when no one is in the church,like at 1:00AM.

I don't care for the provoking part.Too bad one of those British Soldiers didn't knock her on her butt.Now that would have been great tv. By the way,where is this church?
Funny about the Halloween stuff in the church.Around here several of the churches like the Baptist do something around Halloween,but THEY call it a Harvest festival,yeah right. If they were so concerned about the spooky aspects of the holiday and satan and all, then don't even have any festival around Halloween.

The Doctor @ 5:30 pm

Maybe they should just tell the priest to RTFM :-)

Angelayo1970 @ 6:50 pm

There was one "debunk" that bothered me on this investigation. When Steve and Tango are in the storage room where people have seen shadows moving past the windows, Steve gets the bright idea to go outside and look at Dave walking around to see if he can see him walking past. Well, of course, he can and he does. DEBUNKED! Really? Okay…but do we know for a fact that EVERY SINGLE TIME someone has seen a shadowy figure walk past the windows, someone was in the church? I mean, is someone present in the church 24 hours a day, 7 days a week? Yes, it IS probably people walking around up there MOST of the time people see shadows. But I don't think you can say "We debunked the shadows moving in front of the windows because Steve could see Dave Tango walking by up there when he was outside." Well NO DOUBT!!

I don't know, that one just bothered me.

hammer1 @ 9:04 pm

A Church with ghost tours. Why I never….. :)

(Richmond is a section of Staten Island IIRC)

http://www.silive.com/entertainment/recreation/index.ssf/2007/10/the_awe_halloween_guide.html

"Fright Night," tomorrow, Saturday, 7 to 10 p.m. Church of St. Andrew's, 40 Mill Rd., Richmond. Admission: $5. 718-351-0900.

It's time for a different kind of spiritual awakening at the Church of St. Andrew's "Fright Night." Explore the "haunted" catacombs, bone yard, library, jail and country inn. Storytelling, cookies and coffee await at the end. Recommended for brave souls 10 or older.

September 26, 2009

The Doctor @ 12:19 am

Angelayo1970-
"Okay…but do we know for a fact that EVERY SINGLE TIME someone has seen a shadowy figure walk past the windows, someone was in the church? "

Not sure what you are going for here –

If the claim is that Casper closes a door, and investigators find a window that if open will allow enough wind to blow the door shut, it does not make sense to persue the investigation of that incident much further.

It appears that with your EVERY SINGLE TIME condition you are expecting extraordinary proof of what seems to be a very ordinary occurance.

Angelayo1970 @ 12:26 pm

No Doc, not expecting it. I understand the concept of debunking something based on "this is most likely what is happening". It just bothers me to a degree that it's stated in an almost mocking way "how could anyone think it could possibly be anything else?" I mean, if it's happening a lot when the church is empty, there has to be another explanation than someone walking past the windows.

I guess what I was trying to say that didn't come across is…is this claim happening most often when the church is empty? Because if it is, you can't claim to have debunked it using the methodology they used.

September 27, 2009

The Doctor @ 5:23 pm

"I guess what I was trying to say that didn't come across is…is this claim happening most often when the church is empty?"

Well, our investigators never ask that question and the priest dosen't address it, so we might assume that no one ever followed up on it – In itself that's strange since the priest says that HE saw some darkening, yet dosen't mention that he was concerned enough to check out if someone was in his church.

It appears that groups are allowed to hunt in the church -
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CzT15TteoJc

I wonder why the good father never mentioned this video ?

September 28, 2009

Mary @ 9:49 am

I was left wondering why the 'footsteps' in the chapel (heard by Kris and Amy) were so quickly dismissed. In other 'investigations' the sounds have not been nearly as clear to the viewer at home, yet those noises were declared as ghost footsteps. (Do we remember the infamous "let's toss flour on the floor and see if the ghost leaves a Nike footprint?" episode?) What is considered 'ghostly' as opposed to 'not-ghostly' leaves me confused. Why did we not hear those noises amplified during the reveal, and at least tell the viewer what is was, if not a ghost?

M. Roget @ 10:32 am

On further reviewing freeze frames of the debunked still photo in St. Andrew's basement showing possible noose- just freeze it & have a close look on the right hand side of the pic. I've decorated enough Halloween charity haunts for my former parish in Pasadena to know fake, white clumpy cobwebs hanging down when I see them. The cheap ones clump/thread all over the place, so that loopy little noose image can be solved then & there. At least GH did debunk this, & it could hardly have been difficult for them if they looked at the pic for more than 2 seconds.

Someone standing behind the fake cobwebbing on the right of the pic is wearing black makeup around mouth & eyes. Does St. Andrew's Halloween fundraiser include a spooky walkthrough of their under-church catacombs? That would be a wee bit strange, imo. Not too many Halloween haunts, hayrides, etc that I'm aware of take place in real churches, graveyards, mortuaries, etc. Father Mike would have a good time explaining his authorizing the actual church/graveyard usage to most of the Anglican priests I've known.

BrendaLee @ 1:25 pm

While we've not used the actual church for a haunting, we have created haunted houses at our local church, in the youth building. When we are not using our scary supplies, we store them in the church attic. So, it is not too unusual to see those supplies in a church basement.

I think the "noose" was probably a thread; I have the same problem with my phone camera. Threads often hang in front of the lense and would impact the photo if I let them.

M. Roget @ 2:28 pm

I hear you, Brenda. Holliston Avenue Church, my old parish, used to put on a wonderful Halloween haunt fundraiser every year. It was held in the parish school & its yard located behind the main church building. The reason I thought perhaps St. Andrew was using the basement to stage part of their haunt was a) the faux cobwebs draped near the right side of the debunked photo b) hammer1's comment upstairs in this thread that basically says they did just that back in 2007. Here's the link hammer1 dug up on this (and btw, great leg work finding it, h1!):

http://www.silive.com/entertainment/recreation/index.ssf/2007/10/the_awe_halloween_guide.html

Have to love the way the announcement says you'll be touring the catacombs AND the "bone yard." I sure hope they meant a Halloween version of one they set up for the kiddies & not the actual cemetery grounds we saw so much of in this GH ep.




^ Please Support our Sponsor

Leave a Comment

Subscribe without commenting

Copyright 2010 SkepticalViewer.com - The Ghost Hunters Fansite for Skeptics